In the morning, I made my way by bus to the archaeological site of Knossos. Never in my life have I been more disappointed in a site as I was today. Knossos is a site of the Ancient Minoan civilization, who’s sculpture, building, and frescoes have been said to be well ahead of their time (1900-1450 BC). The remains on this site were of a Palatial town in that the center was composed of a the kings palace, while other dwellings were created adjacent to it. In the late 1800’s Sir Arthur Evans among others founded the site, and began excavations. As laws of archaeological sites changed in the 1920’s so did the teams mission on the site. With little funding, Evans funded a project that made many assumptions about the site by “rebuilding” what was there previously in an irreversible way. What I mean by this is that Evan’s team used “educated” assumptions about the site and began concrete construction on top of the existing ruins in order to allow visitors to “imagine” what the palace would have been like. He has painted columns and, laid concrete painted as though they have wood grain or geological properties similar to those on the site… The bottom line is, as it exists today there is very little anyone can do to return the site to the way it was before (as actual ruins) and study what it was rather than what it might have been. Also, it acts like a theme park at this point. I found myself laughing all the way through the site, less interested in the ruins, and more intrigued what a 20th century take on Minoan civilization looks like while tourists climb on the rocks to snap photos while being yelled at by the lifeguard-style officials stationed throughout the site. Knossos is an absolute tragedy and most tourists (because their guides blind them to the “liberties” Evans took on the site).
Sunday, August 23, 2009
Tuesday, August 18th - Knossos/Rethymno
In the morning, I made my way by bus to the archaeological site of Knossos. Never in my life have I been more disappointed in a site as I was today. Knossos is a site of the Ancient Minoan civilization, who’s sculpture, building, and frescoes have been said to be well ahead of their time (1900-1450 BC). The remains on this site were of a Palatial town in that the center was composed of a the kings palace, while other dwellings were created adjacent to it. In the late 1800’s Sir Arthur Evans among others founded the site, and began excavations. As laws of archaeological sites changed in the 1920’s so did the teams mission on the site. With little funding, Evans funded a project that made many assumptions about the site by “rebuilding” what was there previously in an irreversible way. What I mean by this is that Evan’s team used “educated” assumptions about the site and began concrete construction on top of the existing ruins in order to allow visitors to “imagine” what the palace would have been like. He has painted columns and, laid concrete painted as though they have wood grain or geological properties similar to those on the site… The bottom line is, as it exists today there is very little anyone can do to return the site to the way it was before (as actual ruins) and study what it was rather than what it might have been. Also, it acts like a theme park at this point. I found myself laughing all the way through the site, less interested in the ruins, and more intrigued what a 20th century take on Minoan civilization looks like while tourists climb on the rocks to snap photos while being yelled at by the lifeguard-style officials stationed throughout the site. Knossos is an absolute tragedy and most tourists (because their guides blind them to the “liberties” Evans took on the site).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment